In February 1927 the blacksmith shop and barn were purchased from the Culver family for $2,800 and served as the original fire house for 26 years. The first fire truck was purchased in March 1927 and delivered that summer. In the fall of that year a siren was bought (electric was installed the same year,) tower purchased and installed by January, 1928. In August, 1928, the first 32' ladder was purchased. A second truck was added in late 1938. The first recorded fire call was in July 29, 1927, a truck fire on county road west of Colts Neck. In November, 1929, a motion was made to hold company business meetings on the first Tuesday of each month, as they are still held at that time today.

October 30, 1967: The historic structure of Bucks Mill burned to the ground, leaving on the mill wheel as mute evidence. An item in the newspaper was quoted :. "...we have pretty much ruled out juvenile vandalism as the cause of all but one of six suspicious fires including a blaze early Tuesday morning which wrecked Bucks Mill."

1968: The D.O. Evans barn burned. Firemen had to use axes and torches to chip ice from the brook to get to the water. This year the Flock barn also burned. William and Dick Flock still had to milk the cows after the fire. The firemen stayed to help get the cows back in stantions.

November 14, 1972: The historic Phalanx building burned down. The Daily Register noted in an article dated Nov. 15, 1972, "...more than 200 volunteer firemen from area fire companies were unable to save the historic Phalanx Building which burned last night. A total of 24 pieces of apparatus were on the scene. Due to a lack of hydrants in Colts Neck, water had to be drawn from surrounding streams. Middletown Fire Co. pumpers drew water from a pond along Richdale Rd. while Colts Neck units drew water from the brook in front of the property along Phalanx. Nearly two miles of hose was laid as pumpers added their power to keep water pressure up. Trucks and lines of hose had to be snaked through surrounding woods in order to enable firemen to get close to the burning structure. The general alarm was sounded approximately 11 p.m. and the fire was not placed under control until 1:30 a.m. and the general recall was sounded at 3:15 a.m."

March 12, 2004:Firefighters from nearly every company in western and southern Monmouth County joined forces to battle a fierce fire at an uninhabited, nearly-completed mansion on Route 537. The fire began at about 5:30pm in the upper levels of the residence. By 6:30, the area of sprawling fields of which the house was set on was swarming with emergency personnel. By 7pm, the central roof collapsed into the building and the fire was reported under control by 9pm, though it continued to burn until the early morning. Investigations showed that the cause of the fire was electrical malfunction. As of 1994, Chiefs are elected to two-year terms alternating between each company

Conrad H. Decher ~1927-1929 James Higgins * 1930-1931 William Norman * 1932 Arthur Soffel 1933 Martin Riley * 1934 Karl Soffel 1935-1936 Martin Riley 1937-1938 Harold Gunther, Sr 1939-1940 Edwin Sherman 1941 John Riley ~1942-1944 William Pillis 1945-1947 Charles Crine 1948-1949 William Pillis 1950 George Decher 1951 John Koster 1952-1953 Garrett Thompson 1954-1955 William Miles 1956-1957 Howard Quabeck 1958-1959 Granville LeMeune 1960-1961 Stanley Herbert 1962 Jesse Boyle 1963 Granville LeMeune 1964-1965 Joseph Wilson 1966 George Downes* 1967 William Murray 1968 Joseph Lockwood* 1969 William Pillis 1970 George Downes* 1971 Robert Baggitt 1972 David Lott 1973 Richard McCoy 1974 David Lott 1975 Richard McCoy 1976 Benjamin Arnella 1977